Partner
Mission-Critical E-Commerce Dispute: Challenging Brand Leadership
In New York Supreme Court, Woods Lonergan PLLC filed a minority shareholder derivative action, marking a complex commercial dispute over corporate integrity and leadership accountability against the Managing Member and CEO of a prominent e-commerce luxury jewelry retailer. The significant legal challenge of this complex partnership dispute arose from serious allegations of misconduct at the highest levels of the company, impacting its financial health and future.
The Heart of the Partnership Dispute: Allegations of Self-Dealing, Corporate Waste, and Restrictive Covenant Breach
Woods Lonergan brought forth this derivative lawsuit, alleging it stemmed from a managing member simultaneously working at a competitor and drawing a salary there, while also being compensated by the client company’s original entity. The complaint, filed in New York Supreme Court, detailed serious breaches of fiduciary duty, self-dealing, corporate waste, and breach of a restrictive covenant. The alleged scheme carried out by the Managing Member and CEO involved diverting revenue, selling products below profit to competitors, failing to collect substantial receivables (exceeding $560,000), and misusing company resources for personal benefit. This systematic misconduct caused significant financial harm to the company, leading to a demand for damages of not less than approximately $4.5 million, including lost revenue (approximately $3.5 million) and salary forfeiture (approximately $432,000).
The Legal Challenge: Navigating Derivative Action Complexities
Representing the minority shareholder, Woods Lonergan PLLC initiated this derivative action, asserting demand futility due to the defendants’ control and self-interest within the company. A pivotal early victory in the litigation was successfully defeating the defendant’s motion to dismiss the claims of fiduciary duty. This critical ruling in New York Supreme Court validated the compelling nature of the allegations, thereby significantly bolstering our client’s claims and strategic position.
If your business is impacted by corporate misconduct or shareholder disputes, Woods Lonergan PLLC delivers decisive legal action. For a free and confidential consultation, contact our Commercial Litigation team at (332) 378-0376. In select matters, Woods Lonergan reserves hybrid contingency fees arrangements in matters involving claims over $3 Million Dollars.
New York Shareholder Dispute Litigation: Precision in Challenging Corporate Leadership
Woods Lonergan’s Strategic Approach focused on rigorously establishing the defendants’ liability and comprehensively quantifying the extensive damages incurred by the company. This required our New York Partnership trial lawyers to rigorously analyze the evidence, proving the alleged self-dealing, corporate waste, and breach of restrictive covenants. Such an approach attests to our firm’s deep expertise in corporate disputes, breach of fiduciary duty, corporate governance, e-commerce litigation, and restrictive covenant matters. Furthermore, our Commercial Litigation team offers clients a distinct home-field advantage in New York State, leveraging our exceptionally keen on-the-ground understanding of New York’s judicial system and its complex rules of practice and regulatory regimes.
The Outcome: Securing a Substantial, Confidential Multi-Million Dollar Settlement for Our Client
Following the successful defeat of the defendant’s motion to dismiss the claims, the matter proceeded to intensive mediation. This process resulted in a substantial, confidential multi-million dollar settlement. This resolution secured significant compensation for the client, directly addressing the substantial financial harm stemming from diverted revenue, uncollected receivables, and the faithless servant claims. The outcome protected our client’s shareholder interests and addressed the alleged systemic misconduct within the company.
Strategic Counsel for Corporate & Shareholder Disputes
When your enterprise faces complex corporate disputes or partnership conflicts, strategic business owners in New York turn to Woods Lonergan PLLC for formidable representation. Our New York business lawyers provide comprehensive guidance and fierce protection across corporate disputes, breach of contract, shareholder litigation, breach of fiduciary duty claims, and restrictive covenants. As a firm recognized for its broad litigation capabilities and our record of securing favorable outcomes in high-stakes, complex litigation, we strategically optimize resolutions whether through successful court-sanctioned settlement conferences, mediations, and binding arbitration, or by vigorously taking your partnership dispute or corporate dispute to trial when necessary.
For a free and confidential consultation, Call our Commercial Litigation team at (332) 378-0376. Woods Lonergan PLLC is committed to securing the compensation due to its clients. Our selectivity in case engagement, coupled with the availability of hybrid contingency arrangements in appropriate matters, ensures our interests are fully aligned with client goals.
About Woods Lonergan PLLC
Woods Lonergan PLLC operates as a boutique litigation firm. In New York, our experienced trial attorneys have forged our reputation as a litigation powerhouse. For the past 30 years, our firm has demonstrated extensive capabilities in complex and commercial litigation, coupled with a history of achieving significant victories, leveling the playing field for astute individuals, business owners, closely held, mid-size, SMEs, and family-owned enterprises facing formidable adversaries. We are known for achieving significant victories in high-stakes multi-million-dollar litigation against major entities and corporations represented by large law firms.
Our approach allows us to be exceptionally selective in the clients and matters we undertake, ensuring unparalleled dedication and a powerful track record. Our experienced trial lawyers routinely resolve complex breach of contract, corporate disputes encompassing partnership and shareholder matters, business torts such as fraud, and breach of fiduciary claims. We also represent clients in prosecuting and defending restrictive covenants, including non-compete agreements, and litigate claims involving antitrust, unfair competition, and trade secret misappropriation, among other mission-critical disputes across a wide range of industries and sectors. The firm also engages in high-stakes consumer protection and class action litigation, solidifying a proven track record across state, federal, ADR, and Appellate proceedings. Our attorneys regularly argue and take cases to verdicts in critical venues, including New York Supreme Court’s Commercial Division and Federal Appellate Courts.
FAQs: Complex Business Disputes, Shareholder Litigation, and High-Stakes Commercial Litigation in New York
1. Can a minority shareholder sue a company for mismanagement or fraud in New York?
Yes, under New York law, a minority shareholder may bring a derivative lawsuit on behalf of the corporation when insiders—such as officers, directors, or majority shareholders—engage in misconduct that harms the business. Common claims include breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, self-dealing, and corporate waste. These claims are designed to protect the interests of the corporation and, by extension, its shareholders.
Our attorneys have over 30 years of experience guiding clients through the complex procedural requirements of these cases and understand how to strategically structure them to protect corporate value and shareholder interests.
2. What is a derivative lawsuit, and how does it protect minority shareholders?
A derivative lawsuit allows shareholders, typically those without control of the company, to act on behalf of the corporation when those in power misuse their authority. These lawsuits protect minority shareholders when:
- The company’s leadership refuses to address clear misconduct internally.
- Majority shareholders are abusing their position to extract personal benefits at the corporation’s expense.
- The corporation has been materially harmed through fraud, mismanagement, or breaches of fiduciary duty.
These actions seek remedies that benefit the corporation directly, such as recovering lost assets, unwinding improper transactions, or removing bad actors. In turn, this protects the value of all shareholders’ interests.
Our firm understands these disputes are not only about legal theories but about protecting investments, restoring value, and safeguarding the future of the business. Derivative actions are complex and require counsel with trial readiness and strategic foresight.
If you would like to learn more about the difference between direct vs. derivative lawsuits for New York business owners and shareholders, please read our blog: Direct vs. Derivative Claims in New York
3. How long does it take to resolve a shareholder or complex business dispute in New York?
Resolution timelines vary, but complex commercial litigation in New York can take anywhere from 12 to 36 months or more, depending on a range of factors, including:
- The complexity of the claims involved (fraud, accounting irregularities, fiduciary breaches)
- The court’s calendar and jurisdiction
- Whether parallel proceedings are ongoing (such as bankruptcy, regulatory matters, or related lawsuits in other jurisdictions)
- The number of parties involved and whether the dispute crosses multiple jurisdictions
- The willingness of parties to engage in good-faith negotiations
- Strategic motions, discovery disputes, or appeals that may prolong the process
These disputes often involve multiple parties, overlapping claims, and proceedings occurring simultaneously in different forums. Managing these complexities requires litigation counsel experienced in navigating both the procedural and strategic challenges unique to these types of matters.
Our firm understands the cost pressures businesses face during prolonged disputes. Woods Lonergan focuses on moving cases forward strategically and decisively—whether through focused motion practice, meaningful negotiations, or trial. Woods Lonergan’s trial attorneys ensure clients understand not only the process but also the strategy driving each decision.
4. I’ve already hired a law firm, but my case isn’t moving forward. What should I do?
Many of Woods Lonergan’s commercial clients come from other law firms, often “Big Law”, after investing significant resources without seeing meaningful progress. These clients are often frustrated after spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on legal fees, typically at large firms where they’ve had limited access to their attorneys, little transparency, and no clear litigation strategy.
Business owners and shareholders in New York want responsive, proactive counsel with a clear plan to reach resolution. Woods Lonergan steps in to triage stalled matters, refocus strategy, and drive cases toward resolution, whether through settlement or trial. The firm’s trial attorneys are seasoned litigators who understand how to posture a case for maximum leverage, whether the goal is resolution or preparing for trial. They ensure clients understand not just the process, but the strategy behind every step taken.
5. How are attorneys’ fees handled in high-stakes business disputes? Does Woods Lonergan offer hybrid contingency fee structures?
Woods Lonergan’s attorneys are experienced trial lawyers who understand the financial realities and stresses of litigation for business owners. In select matters where the dispute exceeds $3 million, and following a case evaluation, the firm may offer hybrid contingency arrangements.
These hybrid fee structures typically include:
- A reduced hourly rate for legal services
- The client’s commitment to covering out-of-pocket expenses
- A success-based fee contingent on achieving a favorable outcome (settlement, judgment, or recovery)
These arrangements allow Woods Lonergan to share risk with its clients while aligning interests and recognizing the value of achieving a client’s business objectives. Every fee structure is carefully tailored to the complexity, risk profile, and strategic goals of the specific case.
Beyond fees, Woods Lonergan’s experienced litigators know how to posture your case so that you are strategically positioned and fully prepared for trial. If your matter requires being taken to verdict, your case will be structured from the outset to maximize leverage, positioning you for an enhanced valuation at settlement. The firm’s reputation for trial readiness ensures that opposing parties recognize that Woods Lonergan is fully prepared to proceed when necessary.
6. What kinds of damages can be recovered in shareholder or business disputes?
Potential recoveries depend on the legal claims and facts of each case, but commonly include:
- Monetary damages (lost profits, devalued shares, improperly diverted assets)
- Disgorgement of ill-gotten gains by insiders
- Injunctions to stop harmful conduct
- Forced buyouts of minority shareholders at fair value
- Corporate governance reforms to prevent future abuses
- Recovery of attorneys’ fees in appropriate cases
Woods Lonergan works with clients to ensure litigation strategy aligns with desired outcomes—whether financial recovery, corporate restructuring, or holding wrongdoers accountable. The firm’s approach is rooted in understanding each client’s unique business objectives and crafting legal strategies that prioritize efficiency, leverage, and results.
7. What legal options and processes are available to resolve a complex business or shareholder dispute in New York?
Woods Lonergan approaches each dispute with a tailored strategy focused on maximizing leverage, protecting client interests, and achieving results. Legal options include:
Emergency & Preliminary Relief
- Injunctive Relief: Temporary restraining orders (TROs), preliminary injunctions, or orders preserving assets.
- Orders to Show Cause: For urgent matters requiring court intervention.
Litigation in New York Courts
- New York Supreme Court, Commercial Division: Preferred forum for complex commercial disputes due to its specialized judges and rules.
- Federal Court (SDNY, EDNY): Suitable for cases involving federal questions or diversity jurisdiction.
Typical phases include:
- Pleadings: Complaint, Answer, Counterclaims
- Motions Practice: Including dispositive motions
- Discovery: ESI, depositions, financial records
- Settlement Negotiations or Mediation
- Trial Preparation & Trial
- Post-Judgment Motions and Appeals
Appeals
Woods Lonergan is well known for its broad commercial litigation practice in all venues within the New York courts and is well equipped to handle appeals in both state and federal appellate courts. The firm is known for handling complex matters with a lean and efficient approach, delivering the depth of experience required to navigate sophisticated disputes without unnecessary litigation bloat.
Woods Lonergan’s attorneys have a proven track record of success in advancing and defending claims on appeal. They understand how to preserve and position legal issues throughout litigation to strengthen the likelihood of success on appeal. The firm is regularly retained not only to handle appeals arising from its own trial victories but also to take over matters from other firms where fresh appellate strategy and execution are critical.
Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Mediation: Confidential, voluntary negotiations.
- Arbitration: Binding decisions often required by contract.
Woods Lonergan’s attorneys are known for strategically positioning cases for trial from the outset. The firm’s approach demonstrates to opposing parties that it is prepared to take a case to verdict—enhancing leverage for settlement and maximizing valuation opportunities.