At a Glance
For:
New York co-op and condo board members, including sponsor-appointed directors, who want to know who will pay for their defense if they are sued personally.
Why It Matters:
Who brings the lawsuit can change who pays for the defense. If the co-op or condominium sues one of its own board members, the building’s bylaws and insurance policy may leave that member responsible for their own legal bills.

A lawsuit over a New York co-op or condo board decision takes on a different significance when the complaint names a board member personally. The claim may come from a shareholder or unit owner who says the member’s conduct caused them harm. It may also come from the building itself, alleging that a current or former board member breached a duty owed to it. In either case, being named in the complaint does not establish personal liability. It does mean the member needs to know who will pay for a defense.
For counsel advising co-op and condo boards on governance, the distinction is both legal and practical. A board member may have a strong defense and still face legal bills while the case is pending. Whether the building or its insurer will pay those bills depends in part on who brought the claim, what the member is accused of doing, and what the governing documents, applicable law, and insurance policy provide.
When the Building Becomes the Plaintiff
Consider how the same director’s position changes depending on who brings the lawsuit:
- A purchaser sues the co-op and the director. A rejected purchaser alleges that the board member personally participated in a discriminatory decision to deny the application. The co-op and the director must each respond to the purchaser’s claim.
- The co-op sues the director. A new board majority alleges that the director approved a contract with a company in which she held a financial interest. The co-op brings a breach of fiduciary duty claim against the director to recover the building’s alleged loss.
In the first case, the co-op and the board member are defending against the same claim. In the second, the director is asking the co-op to pay for a defense against the co-op’s own lawsuit. A bylaw that provides for reimbursement when a purchaser sues may not extend to a claim brought by the co-op. Whether the insurer will pay is a separate question under the building’s directors and officers policy.
That distinction also matters when an owner files a derivative suit. The owner brings the claim on behalf of the co-op or condominium for harm allegedly done to the building. The board member is therefore defending against the building’s claim, even though an owner filed it. Whether the building is required to pay for the board member’s defense is a separate question.
When the Business Judgment Rule and Bylaws Protect Individual Board Members
Two protections can help a board member defeat a claim for personal liability:
- The business judgment rule. Under Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp. (1990), courts ask only whether a board acted within its authority and in good faith for a legitimate building purpose. Absent fraud, self-dealing, or unconscionability, courts do not second-guess the decision of a Board.
- Limits on personal liability (exculpation). Many bylaws and offering plans limit a board member’s personal liability to cases of bad faith, gross negligence, or willful misconduct.
These protections hold even when the building itself sues. In Board of Managers of Oceanview Condominium v. Riccardi (2d Dep’t 2024), a Staten Island condo board sued its former president, who also owned the penthouse, and tried to make him pay $24,250 in façade fines the building incurred on his watch. The court declined to hold the former president personally responsible for the fines. The board had not shown that the fines resulted from bad faith or willful misconduct, as the bylaws required, or that the president’s actions fell outside the protection of the business judgment rule.
The protections cover only board conduct, however. The same court held the former president responsible for an unpermitted 1,200-square-foot rooftop extension on his own penthouse. As president, he was shielded. As an owner, he was not.
Courts protect good-faith board service and expect any broader protection in writing.
Where the Shield Gives Way: Bad Faith and Divided Loyalty
The business judgment rule protects good-faith decisions, not directors who serve someone other than the building. Sponsor-appointed directors face the greatest risk.
Allegations of bad faith can defeat the rule at the outset. In Owens v. New Empire Corp. (1st Dep’t 2025), Manhattan unit owners alleged that the developer created a separate sponsor entity to dodge liability for defective work, then stacked the board with its own people to stall repairs until it sold every unit. The court let the fiduciary duty claim against those directors proceed, finding the bad-faith allegations sufficient at the pleading stage. The ruling allowed the owners to pursue their fiduciary duty claim; it did not decide whether the directors had breached that duty.
“No claim for damages can make plaintiffs whole where their homes are controlled by unresponsive fiduciaries.”
— Owens v. New Empire Corp. (1st Dep’t 2025)
Once a claim survives, the question becomes who pays for the defense. Three sources answer it.
Three Layers of Protection, Each With Its Own Limits
These protections overlap, but each has gaps the others may not fill.
1. The governing documents: only as good as their wording
Governing documents typically make two promises. Exculpation provisions limit a director’s personal liability. Indemnification provisions go further and cover the director’s legal fees and losses.
Nearly all of them exclude bad faith, gross negligence, and willful misconduct. A director who acted for personal gain or for an outside party should not expect the building to pay.
Scope also matters. New York courts read indemnification provisions strictly. In Sage Systems, Inc. v. Liss (2022), the Court of Appeals reaffirmed that courts will not shift legal costs in a dispute between the parties themselves unless the contract makes the intent to do so unmistakably clear. Broad, general language is not enough.
In 2026, the First Department applied that rule to a condominium’s bylaws in Board of Managers of the 432 Park Condominium v. 56th & Park (NY) Owner, LLC. The bylaws indemnified board members for claims “arising out of” their service, but the court held that this promise did not cover the board’s own fiduciary duty suit against a former member. A clause like that may protect a director against an outside plaintiff but not against the board.
2. The statute: a backstop for co-ops, less certain for condos
New York’s Business Corporation Law (BCL) governs most co-ops. It allows indemnification when a director acts in good faith, and it lets a director ask a court to order indemnification, or the advance of legal fees, when the co-op refuses.
Condominiums fall under a different statute that says little on the subject. At least one Manhattan trial court has filled that gap with the BCL’s rules (Board of Managers of the 28 Cliff Street Condominium v. Maguire, 2019), but condo directors should not count on it.
3. D&O insurance: often silent on the claims that matter most
Indemnification helps only if the building can pay. Directors and officers (D&O) insurance fills that gap by paying defense costs and covered losses directly. Most policies exclude fraud, intentional misconduct, and improper personal profit.
For this topic, the key provision is the “insured versus insured” exclusion. Because the policy insures both the building and its directors, many policies refuse to cover a claim that one insured brings against another, including a suit by the building against its own director. Some policies make an exception for derivative suits brought by owners; others do not.
The result mirrors the governing documents. A policy that readily covers a director against a claim from outside the building may leave them uncovered when the claim comes from within.
Close the Gaps Before the Dispute Begins
Boards can fix most of these gaps through drafting and governance, ideally before any claim arises.
- Check whose claims the indemnification clause covers. Counsel and the board should determine whether the clause covers a board member’s defense costs when the building brings the claim itself or when an owner brings it on the building’s behalf.
- Consider amending the governing documents. Clear, specific language protects directors against claims from within. Follow the building’s amendment procedures, which often require a supermajority owner vote.
- Document how the board makes decisions. Minutes, resolutions, professional advice, and a record of the board’s reasoning help keep directors inside the business judgment rule.
- Read the D&O exclusions. Look for an insured versus insured exclusion and any carve-backs, and ask the broker about broader terms.
- Address advancement of legal fees. Reimbursement at the end of a case does little for a director who must fund years of litigation first.
- Review conflicts involving sponsor-appointed directors. A director appointed by the sponsor owes a duty of loyalty to the condominium. In Owens, the owners alleged that sponsor-appointed directors delayed repairs to benefit the sponsor. Those allegations were specific enough for the fiduciary duty claim to proceed.
- Timing matters. Delay can forfeit indemnification demands, advancement requests, and insurance notice rights.
The Bottom Line
Board members enjoy broad protection, but not unlimited protection. When a director acts in good faith, the business judgment rule and the bylaws may end a claim before anyone asks who pays. When a plaintiff plausibly alleges bad faith or divided loyalty, the claim proceeds, and the governing documents and insurance policy decide who bears the cost.
The details vary by building, but the case law points one way: courts protect good-faith board service and expect any broader protection in writing.
Protecting the Board Members Who Serve Your Building
Woods Lonergan reviews indemnification clauses and D&O policies for co-op and condo boards, drafts amendments to governing documents, and defends directors when claims are brought against them, from the trial court through appeal. Andreas E. Christou advises boards on governance and defends board decisions in state and federal court, including on appeal.
About Woods Lonergan
We represent business owners, privately held companies, family offices and the boards of cooperative and condominium buildings in commercial and real estate matters. We are ranked in Chambers USA: Spotlight New York for Litigation: General Commercial and Real Estate. A board’s work is making a building a better place to live, and that is the work we serve. For more than 30 years, we have counseled boards in Manhattan, Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens, from pre-war landmarks to signature new construction. Every matter is partner-led and calibrated to the building.
When a matter turns contentious, the partners who already know your building see it through. We bill sensibly and transparently, because every legal dollar a board spends is accountable to the community.
Our attorneys are regularly quoted and published on cooperative and condominium law in The New York Times, The Washington Post, Brick Underground, Habitat, The Cooperator and the New York Real Estate Journal.
Our co-op and condo board practice includes:
Governance
- Day-to-day governance counsel
- Annual meetings, proxies and voting procedure
- Election challenges and board takeover defense
- Proprietary leases, bylaws and house rules
- Declaration and bylaw amendments
- Purchase applications, transfers and closings
- Flip taxes and rights of first refusal
- Fair housing and reasonable accommodation requests
- Alteration agreements and renovation approvals
Finance & Assets
- Refinancing and capital improvement financing
- Arrears, lien foreclosures and lease terminations
- Real estate tax assessments
- Ground leases and air rights
Advocacy & Resolution
- Defense of board decisions and fiduciary claims
- D&O insurance coverage for directors
- Shareholder and unit owner claims against the board
- Sponsor turnover and transition to board control
- Sponsor and offering plan enforcement
- Construction defect and §881 access claims
- Contractor, broker commission and vendor claims
- Property damage and claims against the City
- Trial, appeal and ADR
Building & Operations
- Contractor, vendor and managing agent agreements
- Commercial tenants in mixed-use buildings
- Building staff and labor
Have a legal question? Let us assist your building community.
Frequently Asked Questions
If I resign from the board, can I still be sued for decisions I made while serving?
Yes. Leaving the board does not end your exposure for decisions made while you served; that ends only when the time limit for bringing the claim runs out. Whether the building still covers your defense depends on whether the governing documents extend indemnification to former directors. Most D&O policies cover claims made while the policy is in force, so a departing director should ask whether the building keeps continuous coverage or buys extended “tail” coverage when it changes insurers.
Can I be sued personally for a decision the whole board voted on?
You can be named, but New York courts generally will not hold an individual director liable for a collective board decision made in good faith. To reach a director personally, a plaintiff usually must show that the director committed wrongful conduct of their own, separate from the board’s action. Courts have dismissed claims against individual board members where the complaint alleged nothing beyond their vote.
Does it help if I voted against the decision?
It can. A dissent recorded in the minutes is evidence that you did not take part in the action being challenged. New York’s Business Corporation Law presumes that a director present at a meeting agreed to certain board actions unless the dissent is entered in the minutes, so a dissent that is only spoken may not count.
What is the difference between an owner suing the board directly and bringing a derivative suit?
A direct suit claims harm to the owner personally, such as an improper denial of a sublet, and any recovery goes to that owner. A derivative suit claims harm to the building, such as a director’s self-dealing contract. The owner brings it on the building’s behalf, and any recovery goes to the building. Before filing a derivative suit, an owner generally must ask the board to act or explain why asking would be futile. The difference matters for directors because, in a derivative suit, they are defending against what is legally the building’s own claim.
Does the building have to pay my legal fees while the case is pending, or only after it ends?
It depends on the governing documents. New York law allows a co-op to advance a director’s legal fees during the case, in exchange for a written promise to repay them if the director is later found not entitled. Advancement is required only if the bylaws or an agreement make it mandatory; otherwise the board decides. A director can ask a court to order it. For condominiums, the bylaws control.
What should I do first if I’m named in a lawsuit?
Notify the building’s D&O insurer in writing right away, because late notice can cost you coverage. Send the board a written request for indemnification and advance payment of your legal fees. Keep your emails and records, avoid discussing the case with owners or other parties, and get advice on whether you need your own counsel.
Can the board and I use the same lawyer if we’re both sued?
Often, yes, when the building and its directors face the same outside claim and their interests are aligned. Not when the building sues the director, or when the allegations point toward a director’s personal conduct, such as self-dealing. In those cases each side needs separate counsel.
If the insurer is paying for my defense, who chooses my lawyer?
The policy decides. Some D&O policies let the insurer appoint defense counsel, often from an approved list. Others let the insured choose, subject to the insurer’s consent and its rate limits. Where the insurer’s interests conflict with yours, New York law may entitle you to independent counsel at the insurer’s expense.
Can a rejected purchaser sue me personally for discrimination?
Yes. A co-op board may reject a purchaser for almost any reason, but not a discriminatory one. Federal, state and New York City fair housing laws allow claims against individual directors who took part in the discriminatory decision. The business judgment rule does not protect a discriminatory decision. Whether D&O insurance pays for the defense depends on the policy’s terms.
Do unpaid volunteer board members get extra protection under New York law?
Not from the volunteer statute most people have in mind. New York’s special protection for unpaid directors applies to not-for-profit corporations, and most co-ops are business corporations, so it does not reach most co-op boards. A co-op can still limit its directors’ personal liability for damages in its certificate of incorporation, except for bad faith, intentional misconduct and improper personal benefit, and condominium bylaws often include similar protection. Together with the business judgment rule, those provisions are where board members’ protection comes from.
